the most comfortable Bluetooth® sleep mask
Silk Sleep Mask Vs Cotton
A silk sleep mask vs cotton — which will you choose? Read this for the benefits of each and a detailed comparison. Plus, our recommendations and user reviews.
You value your zzzs. That’s why you’re here. Heck, we don’t blame you. And that’s because the importance of good sleep can’t be overstated. It’s what gives you the mental, physical and emotional fuel to live every day at your best.
You’ve likely tried different sleep accessories in your quest for better zzzs. And one of the most simple yet effective ones is a sleep mask. And believe us when we say that the material it’s made from counts.
In this article, we’ll explore two of the most popular ones: a silk sleep mask vs cotton. We’ll delve into the pros and cons so you know which one is best suited to you.
Table of Contents
How Do Sleep Masks Work?
But first, let’s explore what a sleep mask is and how it helps with better zzzs.
An eye mask for sleeping is a piece of fabric that covers your eyes to block out light. And why is that important? It’s pretty simple.
When you see light it tells your brain and body that it’s time to be awake. Darkness, on the other hand, signals them to wind down for bed. And exposure to light too close to bedtime or while you’re trying to drift off can spell poor sleep quality.
Wearing a sleep mask ensures that light doesn’t disrupt your sleep. It’ll help you drift off faster and stay asleep longer.
But not all sleep masks are created equal. Some come with contoured eye cups to keep the pressure off your eyes. Others are adjustable for a comfy and custom fit. They also come in different fabrics. Two of the most popular are silk and cotton.
The next sections will discuss these types of sleep masks and their features.
What Are Silk Sleep Masks?
They’re considered luxury sleep masks provided they’re made from real silk. Plus, they offer numerous skin and hair benefits to boot. Plus, they feel great against your skin, owing to silk’s soft and supple texture.
Benefits of Silk Sleep Masks
They’re gentle on your skin. Silk has a smooth texture that reduces friction against your skin. This minimizes sleep creases and wrinkles, which take longer to disappear as you age.
Silk is also beneficial for your mane. Again, the smooth texture minimizes snagging, tangling and breakage.
Another benefit to consider is silk’s natural hypoallergenic properties. Remember that a sleep mask sits next to two of the most sensitive parts of your body: the skin on your face and your eyes. A silk sleep mask is a must if you have sensitive, allergy-prone skin.
Silk is breathable and regulates temperature. The beauty of a silk sleep mask is you can wear it all year. You can wear it during the summer and not have to worry about overheating. Or wear it during the winter without feeling too cold.
Also, depending on the momme (or weight) of the silk sleep mask, it can be more effective at blocking out light due to the dense weave.
Want to learn more? Check out our article on silk eye mask benefits.
What Are Cotton Sleep Masks?
Now let’s move on to cotton sleep masks. They’re known most for being soft and comfy, especially when the cotton is high-quality.
Cotton Sleep Mask Benefits
As we mentioned earlier, cotton is popular for its softness. It feels cozy against your skin, which can lead to a soothing sleep experience.
Like silk, cotton is also breathable. It also absorbs moisture from the skin around your eye area, regulating your body temperature. This means your cotton sleep mask will help prevent overheating during sleep.
Cotton eye masks for sleep are also known for their durability. They’re usually machine-washable, which makes them a practical option.
Silk Sleep Mask vs Cotton: A Detailed Comparison
When choosing between a silk sleep mask and a cotton one, several factors come into play such as comfort, durability, breathability, and light blocking.
Comparing Silk and Cotton Sleep Masks
Comfort
Silk and cotton sleep masks both provide comfort, but each with a different feel. Silk is luxurious, supple and smooth whereas cotton is soft and cozy.
Skin Friction
Silk’s smooth texture means less friction on the skin. This reduces the formation of wrinkles and creases when the mask presses against your face.
A silk eye mask may be a better choice in the long run in this aspect. Cotton can leave marks.
Maintenance
Most silk sleep masks require special care. They’re either handwashed or dry-cleaned. To see what we mean, read our article on how to wash a silk eye mask.
Meanwhile, cotton sleep masks are usually machine-washable. That’s why when it comes to durability, cotton scores higher. They typically hold their shape longer, too.
There’s a "but" though. We said most silk sleep masks require special care. Keep on reading to learn more about a 100% machine-washable silk eye mask.
Breathability
Both silk and cotton are breathable and temperature-regulating. A cotton sleep mask tends to absorb more moisture. And it also stays wet for longer.
Gentle On Skin
Both cotton and silk have hypoallergenic properties. But silk’s smooth texture makes it more resistant to allergens buildup. Meanwhile, cotton tends to accumulate more dirt, dust mites and mold.
Light-blocking
Silk sleep masks are typically better at blocking out light, thanks to the dense weave. While cotton masks can also do a good job, they might not be as efficient at preventing all light from seeping through.
Cost
We won’t lie. Silk sleep masks are often pricier than cotton ones. The higher the weight, the better the quality. But remember, they have additional benefits. And that’s why they’re worth the investment.
Factors to Consider When Purchasing a Sleep Mask
So, now you’re aware of how a cotton silk mask compares with a silk one. It should be easier for you to make a decision. It’s really about personal preference, too.
For instance, if you prioritize skincare, then a silk sleep mask is the better choice. If comfort and softness are more up your alley, then consider a cotton one. Then, there’s pricing and maintenance to consider, too.
But there are other factors to look out for when choosing any sleep mask. Here are a few:
Shape
The mask should cover your eyes completely while leaving enough space for your nose. Some eye masks come with eye cups that ensure no light leaks through. The cups also prevent the mask from putting pressure on your eyes and lashes.
Adjustability
The head strap should ideally be adjustable. This is so you get a custom fit. Keep in mind that the head strap should be snug enough to stay put the whole night even if you switch sides. That said, if it comes with eye cups, these should be adjustable to fit your eye area.
Forget sleep masks with a single elastic strap. They aren’t durable and they’ll lose their shape sooner.
Light-blocking
We already talked about this earlier. But the first thing you should look for in a sleep mask is 100% blackout. Otherwise, it won’t perform its main function.
Cotton Vs Silk Sleep Mask: Our Recommendations
While we don’t offer masks that are made from 100% cotton, we do have several that are partly made from it. View our complete collection.
Manta Sleep Mask
An example is our original, Manta SLEEP Mask. It comes with a pair of convex eye cups for zero pressure on your eyes and lashes. Not to mention helps block out light by 100%.
The head strap secures around your head with a micro hook and loop closure for a custom fit. Both the strap and eye cups are fully adjustable.
Here’s a breakdown of its materials and additional features:
-
The head strap is crafted from a mix of cotton and polyester. The interior of the strap, which touches your face, is made from cotton velour. The exterior is made from polyester.
-
The eye cups are crafted from foam. They’re encased in super soft modal fabric that’s sourced from beech trees.
-
The mask’s fabric is super soft and breathable.
-
The head strap is made with triple-reinforced elastic for durability.
-
We designed the mask for all positions, including side sleeping.
-
The head strap and the eye cups are 100% machine washable. They come with a mesh storage bag that also doubles as a laundry case.
Manta Sleep Mask User Testimonials
Here’s what users have to say about their experience:
Black out
“All I can say is I wish I found this sooner in life…having issues with sleep for the better part of 10 years this mask helps tremendously by not only blocking out light entirely but it also trains the brain to know when it’s time to sleep. I’ve had no issues falling asleep since using it. Great product for anyone with issues falling asleep for sure.”
— Ryan S.
“Its really nice and worth it. I work night shifts every 3 weeks and this mask saves the day (haha)! It doesn't let the light in once you ajust it to your face shape and its very comfy. You can even open your eyes in it and there is no pressure on your eyelids/lashes. I bought one for my boyfriend too cause he doesn't have curtains in his room and he sleeps better now that the sun doesn't wake him up early in the morning. We're very satisfied :)”
— Emmanuelle T.
“It is amazing how well I sleep when it is complete darkness! I can pretty much sleep anywhere and at any time with the Manta sleep mask, including the bedrooms at work where there is really no proper curtains.”
— Nikolai Q.
“I love the eye mask..it's easy on the face and cuts out the morning light here in Brisbane. I highly recommend it.”
— John N.
Manta SILK Sleep Mask
And now let’s move on to the Manta Sleep mask that’s crafted from near 100% pure silk, Manta SILK Sleep Mask.
Like our original sleep mask, this one comes with a set of eye cups that provide zero pressure on your peepers and eyelashes. This washable sleep mask is also 100% blackout with a head strap that’s fully adjustable like the cups.
Here are its features:
-
The head strap is crafted from 92% 22 momme silk. The strap’s filling is breathable and made from silk fiber.
-
The strap is textured to prevent the mask from slipping off your head as you sleep. It also stays put thanks to the micro hook and loop closure.
-
The mask’s fabric is buttery soft to the touch and breathable.
-
The eye cups are crafted from 100% 30 momme silk, which is gentle on your skin and minimizes sleep wrinkles and creases.
-
They’re also extra tapered so you won’t feel bulk on your temples.
-
It’s designed for all sleeping positions.
-
Unlike most silk sleep masks, this one is 100% machine washable and comes with a mesh storage/laundry case.
-
Comes in a luxurious royal blue color.
Manta SILK Mask User Testimonials
Check out these reviews from Manta SILK Sleep Mask Users:
Best mask they have
“I have a really small head and I have ordered five or six different masks from this place because I love their masks. This one fits my head perfectly and helps my lashes stay safe.”
— Annabelle S.
Best silk sleep mask!
“Light weight, cool, and doesn’t cause breakouts! Fully black out too.”
— Deirdre O.
I’m now a believer!
“I love this mask! Super functional, comfortable, and I love how futuristic it looks. The matching earplugs and mesh bag were also a really nice touch! I apply eyelash serum right before bed, and this mask makes sure it doesn’t smear all over my face while I sleep. I was hesitant to get this initially when I saw the price tag, but honestly this is such a great purchase. I sleep so well with my mask!”
— Jahona D.
The best
“I own 3 manta sleep masks, this one, the old silk version and the glow in the dark. This one is by far the best. The eye cups are thinner so side sleeping is much easier and the texture on the back keeps it on my head. No more slipping off my head!”
— Mandi B.
Cotton Vs Silk Sleep Mask: What’s the Verdict?
So, Silk Sleep Mask vs Cotton, which one is your choice? Like we said, the answer is all about what suits you best. Now that you’re armed with the information you need, deciding will be much easier.
If you’re after luxurious comfort and additional skin and hair benefits, then the best silk sleep mask may be what you’re looking for. And if you’re looking for softness and comfort, you might want to go with a cotton sleep mask.
Don't forget that good quality sleep gives you the energy to live a healthy life. Choose which type of sleep mask fits your needs best and enjoy the deep, restful sleep you deserve.
If you have any feedback on either of the sleep masks, let others know. Drop a comment below.
Disclaimer: The information contained in this website or provided through our blog, e-mails, or programs is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to be a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment that can be provided by your healthcare professionals.